Hotels in Sister Bay

Embrace the Enchantment of Sister Bay: Where Shoreline Serenity Meets Cultural Charm

Nestled along the picturesque Door Peninsula, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, is a charming escape that beautifully blends natural beauty and local heritage. Known for its stunning Sister Bay Beach, visitors can relax on sandy shores or explore the vibrant waterfront filled with quaint shops and eateries. Don’t miss the scenic views from Little Sister Hill, perfect for hiking enthusiasts. The heart of Sister Bay pulses with cultural events, showcasing the region's rich history and community spirit. Whether you're seeking romance, adventure, or a peaceful retreat, Sister Bay offers an unforgettable experience surrounded by the breathtaking landscapes of Sturgeon Bay and beyond. For the best hotel rates in Sister Bay and to enhance your stay, be sure to check out Hotels.com's Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window on travel.

Top locations to stay in Sister Bay

Some of the best places to stay in Sister Bay are Sturgeon Bay, Fish Creek and Egg Harbor. Sister Bay, Wisconsin, along with nearby Sturgeon Bay, Fish Creek, and Egg Harbor, offers a delightful range of experiences for travelers. Sturgeon Bay boasts waterfront charm and vibrant art scenes, while Fish Creek is perfect for outdoor adventures and dining. Egg Harbor features scenic views and boutique shopping. Accommodation options are diverse, from cozy inns to resorts with plenty of amenities, catering to all budgets. For first-time visitors, Fish Creek is highly recommended for its welcoming atmosphere and activities. These are some of the hotels preferred by our travelers in Sister Bay:

1. Sturgeon BayOpens in a new window: Sturgeon Bay is a fantastic destination for outdoor enthusiasts, featuring attractions like Cave Point County Park for wellness and relaxation, and Potawatomi State Park for adventure seekers. The Sturgeon Bay Bridge adds a cultural touch to this vibrant area. For accommodations, consider Chanticleer Guest HouseOpens in a new window, a 4.0-star Bed & Breakfast that offers adventure sports like ice skating and snowshoeing. Another option is Inn at Cedar CrossingOpens in a new window, a 3.5-star Inn providing nearby bicycle rentals and horseback riding, perfect for those looking for an active getaway. Lastly, Garden Gate BnBOpens in a new window, also a 3.5-star Bed & Breakfast, offers complimentary breakfast and entertainment options like cable TV, making it a cozy choice for travelers.
2. Fish CreekOpens in a new window: Fish Creek is a charming location known for its beautiful beaches and outdoor activities, with Peninsula State Park offering stunning scenery and adventure opportunities. The area is also home to the Door Community Auditorium, ideal for cultural experiences. For your stay, Thorp House Inn & CottagesOpens in a new window is a 4.0-star Bed & Breakfast with direct beach access and adventure sports like kayaking. Alternatively, Settlement Courtyard Inn & Lavender SpaOpens in a new window, a 3.5-star Bed & Breakfast, is family-friendly, providing amenities for children and onsite hiking. For a budget-friendly option, consider Julie's Park Cafe and MotelOpens in a new window, a 2.5-star Motel that welcomes pets, making it great for travelers with furry friends.
3. Egg HarborOpens in a new window: Egg Harbor boasts beautiful beaches and scenic parks, perfect for outdoor lovers. Egg Harbor Beach and Peninsula State Park are highlights, alongside the charming Harbor Ridge Winery for a touch of romance. For lodging, The Feathered Star B&BOpens in a new window, a 3.5-star Bed & Breakfast, accommodates pets and offers a welcoming atmosphere. Newport ResortOpens in a new window, a 3.0-star hotel, focuses on adventure with activities like snow tubing and hiking available nearby. Another option is The AshbrookeOpens in a new window, also a 3.0-star hotel, featuring fitness facilities and entertainment options, ensuring a comfortable stay for guests.

Things to do in Sister Bay for first time

Three days in Sister Bay is ideal for immersing yourself in the natural beauty of Door Peninsula. Enjoy hiking scenic trails, boating on serene waters, and exploring charming shops. Don’t miss the vibrant festivals and the relaxing beach atmosphere, making it a perfect getaway for nature lovers and adventure seekers alike. Here's a quick itinerary to make the most of your trip to Sister Bay:

• Day 1: Start your adventure in Sister Bay with a visit to Peninsula State Park, where you can explore its stunning hiking trails and scenic views. Next, make your way to the Eagle Bluff Lighthouse Museum, a charming historical site that offers fascinating insights into the area's maritime history. Afterward, unwind at Nicolet Bay Beach, perfect for a relaxing afternoon by the water—ideal for a swim or a picnic while soaking in the natural beauty.
• Day 2: Begin your day at Eagle Harbor, where you can enjoy the picturesque views and perhaps spot some local wildlife. Following your harbor visit, head to Water Street Gallery, an excellent spot to appreciate local art and maybe even pick up a unique souvenir. Continue your artistic journey at Francis Hardy Gallery, showcasing a diverse range of works from talented regional artists, making it a must-see for art lovers.
• Day 3: Kick off with a trip to Newport State Park, known for its serene landscapes and abundant wildlife—perfect for hiking or biking along its peaceful trails. Next, visit the iconic Cana Island Lighthouse, where you can learn about its history and enjoy breathtaking views of Lake Michigan. Finally, relax at Ephraim Public Beach, where you can unwind on the sandy shores and take in the beautiful sunset to wrap up your trip.

5 tips to find a great Sister Bay hotel deal

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly times to visit Sister Bay are March, November, and December, when hotel rates are more affordable. If you're traveling from abroad, it's wise to book your flight at least six months in advance to secure the best prices. To fully appreciate the area, plan for a stay of at least 2-3 days, which will allow you to explore the beautiful lake, beach, and nearby state parks. This way, you can enjoy great value for money while discovering the main attractions Sister Bay has to offer.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: If you're looking for last-minute deals to Sister Bay, consider exploring options on Hotels.com. Visit the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window section to view a variety of hotel deals with good availability near your travel date. You may discover discounted rates that fit your budget. Additionally, enabling email alerts or push notifications can keep you informed about flash sales and special promotions, helping you compare prices and potentially score great rates for your stay.
3. Be flexible with dates: Hotel prices can fluctuate due to factors like the location, star rating, and season. Therefore, if you’re flexible with your travel dates, you may save on hotel expenses in Sister Bay.
4. Consider your location: Staying in the city center and close to local attractions in Sister Bay is usually more expensive. If you opt for accommodations further away from the city center, you can take advantage of transportation options like a car, bicycle, or walking to explore the area while potentially saving on costs.
5. Upgrade with One Key: Book your next stay in Sister Bay and join Hotels.com’s One Key programme which allows members to earn and redeem rewards points for hotel bookings. Move through blue, silver, gold and platinum tiers and unlock benefits such as earning free nights, room upgrades, special discounts, and exclusive deals for members. Sign up now.

What to eat in Sister Bay

Here are some top-rated dishes in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States of America:

• Fish Boil: A quintessential Door County experience, fish boils are a community tradition where whitefish is cooked in a large pot over an open flame. The dish is prepared with potatoes and onions, creating a hearty meal. As the water reaches a boil, kerosene is added to create a dramatic effect, causing the water to bubble over, which helps remove excess fat. This communal cooking method embodies the spirit of togetherness, often served at local fish boil restaurants, where diners can enjoy the meal with family and friends, surrounded by the beautiful landscapes of Sister Bay.
• Door County Cherry Pie: This beloved dessert features a flaky crust filled with tart Door County cherries, a nod to the region's rich agricultural heritage. Often served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, it’s a perfect way to conclude a meal. Many bakeries in Sister Bay proudly showcase their take on this classic, making it a must-try for anyone seeking an authentic taste of the area.

Best time to go to Sister Bay

Sister Bay experiences its lowest average temperature in February, at 21.4°F (-5.9°C), while August is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 67.6°F (19.8°C). June is usually the wettest month. June to August are the peak travel months in Sister Bay, attracting a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, with light rainfall. On the other hand, January, November, and December tend to be quieter times to visit, marked by dry to light rainfall and mostly cloudy conditions.