I’ve stayed at Hotel New York many times and I’ll keep going back. The staff is always friendly and attentive. Check-in and check out is fast. The rooms are clean, housekeeping made daily and has a safe for your valuables. The rooms are simple but clean. Come prepared, bring your toiletries as you only get a small bar soap.
The area is safe and quiet. That’s my personal experience. Lots to do around hotel, restaurants, convenience stores, subways, etc all near by. About a pleasant 1/2 hr walk to Historic Center.
This trip we came across (it had never happened before), some noisy guests just outside the elevator. I did call them out though. Like come on! Keep it quiet, people are trying to sleep at 5:30 am! This a hotel where families with kids and elders stay. Show some respect and courtesy for other guests. There a clear signs on each floor and as you exit each elevator to be quiet in guest room floors. This however has been the only time though I’ve heard noisy guests. The other trips, other guests were respectful. Hotel is not to be blamed though for noisy and disrespectful guests.
As always my over all experience at Hotel New York is always pleasant. I will return.