Hotels in Hay Beach, Shelter Island

your current months are December, 2024 and January, 2025.
December 2024
January 2025

Find and book your perfect stay

Earn rewards on every night you stay
Save more with Member Prices
Free cancellation options if plans change

Where to stay in Hay Beach?

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Top landmarks in Shelter Island

Find out more about Hay Beach

What's Hay Beach like?

If you want to find the perfect part of the city to explore, why not consider Hay Beach? Take time to see the sights such as Menhadden Lane Beach while you're here. Greenport Carousel and Railroad Museum of Long Island are two places to visit nearby.

How to get to Hay Beach

Flying to:

  • East Hampton, NY (HTO), 10.5 mi (16.9 km) from Hay Beach
  • Fishers Island, NY (FID-Elizabeth Field), 18.9 mi (30.5 km) from Hay Beach
  • Montauk, NY (MTP), 21.2 mi (34.1 km) from Hay Beach

Things to see and do in and around Hay Beach

Things to see near Hay Beach:

  • Menhadden Lane Beach (0.8 mi/1.3 km away)
  • Greenport Carousel (1.6 mi/2.6 km away)
  • 67 Steps Beach (2.5 mi/4.1 km away)
  • Sunset Beach (2.6 mi/4.1 km away)
  • Crescent Beach (2.9 mi/4.6 km away)

Things to do near Hay Beach:

  • Railroad Museum of Long Island (1.8 mi/2.9 km away)
  • Kontokosta Winery (2.1 mi/3.4 km away)
  • Gardiner's Bay Country Club (0.5 mi/0.8 km away)
  • Greenport Farmers' Market (1.7 mi/2.7 km away)
  • Island's End Golf and Country Club (1.8 mi/2.8 km away)

When is the best time to visit Shelter Island?

  • Hottest months: August, July, September, June (average 21°C)
  • Coldest months: January, February, March, December (average 3°C)
  • Rainiest months: October, December, March, January (average 143 mm of rainfall)

Keep exploring