"Overall 9/10, main drawback is check-in, which takes a really long time.
We’ve been coming here for years (2009, 2011, 2015, 2018, 2019, 2023), and the food was noticeably improved this trip. Ordering off the menu is still the way to go if the buffet doesn’t have what you’d like. The buffet is average all-inclusive food, but the flattop grill had something decent for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Not the best food we’ve had, but far from the worst.
The grounds show some wear, but the staff works hard to maintain them. Rooms are dated and beds are firm, but we’re barely in the room anyway. Our AC worked great (almost too well), and the TV wasn’t great but not a big deal for us.
The biggest highlight is snorkeling right out front, lots of fish. We would walk to the tidal pool before the Westin and drift back with the current, you’ll see more fish this way. If you’re more adventurous, enter at the Westin, Buccanos or the old condos and float back. I’d use a dive flag or buoy if you choose this route.
The staff truly stands out here, welcoming, kind, and attentive. Aldo, Kevin, Omar, Juan, Yaneth, Santiago, and Paulino were great. The activities team (Cesar, Angel, Leo, Michel) were awesome, and our son loved the kids club.
Big picture, if you expect a 5-star luxury resort, you’ll probably be disappointed. But if you understand what the El Cozumeleno is, take advantage of the pros, and don’t plan to spend a ton of time in your room, you’ll likely be pleasantly surprised. "
